Thursday, July 5, 2012

Central Database of Shoah Victims Names - Part II

Whenever looking at a document, it is important to consider how and why the document was made. This helps to figure out which parts of the document are more likely to be reliable.

For example: on a death certificate, the date, time, and cause of death are all likely to be reliable. Or at least as reliable as the medical profession was at the time. The reliability of the date and place of birth, or information such as the names of the deceased's parents, depends entirely on the informant.

The Central Database of Shoah Victims Names draws its names from three sources:
1.Pages of Testimony. These are one-page forms, submitted to Yad Vashem by survivors, remaining family members or friends in commemoration of people who perished in the Holocaust. The first 800,000 of them were collected in the 1950s, and the rest since. There are currently some 2,600,000 names on Pages of Testimony, written in about thirty languages and four alphabets.


2.Historical documentation from the archives, such as the correspondence of the Nazi bureaucrats and their counterparts throughout Europe; personal documents of the Jews such as letters, passports, diaries and memoirs, as well as the documentation of the Jewish organs and institutions; lists detailing confiscation of assets, deportation lists or lists of victims; legal documentation from proceedings against Nazi criminals and collaborators, and much more. The documentation is in all European languages.


3. Local commemoration projects: There are dozens of local initiatives to record the names of the Jews from a specific region, country, or camp. Yad Vashem has joined efforts with these projects, and their results are integrated into the central database. 
In my searches, most of the results appear to come from pages of testimony.  How reliable are these? Well, consider the circumstances. You are a survivor of the Holocaust. A decade, two, three, or four afterwards you feel compelled to memorialize the names of your relatives and fellow members of your community who perished. The names you are likely to remember well.  Names of parents? If its for a sibling, you will likely get that right. But for a cousin? It might depend upon how old you were at the time. Dates and Places of birth?

In some cases, all the record really provides for certainty is a name. But that is a name you can take to other websites such as JewishGen and see if you can find records to confirm the other pieces of information.

After looking at the records of Almasu/Varalmas I decided to do a search on some paternal ancestors. In particular, the Cantkerts (pronounced: Tsantkerts).

My second great grandparents Samuel and Rose (Cantkert) Newmark lived in Warka, Poland - on the outskirts of Warsaw.  They left Poland in 1893 and after spending 15 years in England, finally settled in America.  All I know for certain about Rose's parents are the names that appear on her death certificate: Hirsch and Bryna.  How well did her son recall the names of his grandparents?  He didn't get Rose's maiden name correct - he wrote it down as Sundberg. Luckily, the London birth records of his younger siblings led me to Cantkert. Are the first names correct?

I conducted a search at the Central Database for anyone with the name Cantkert.  There were only slightly over 60 results, and I created an Excel spreadsheet of information from the records. Here's a table:

Surname First Name Maiden Father Mother DOB POB Spouse Submitter Relationship
Cantker Feiga Holtzman Nisan Pesa 1913 Siedlce Poland Mendel Yeshayahu Holtzman Brother
Cantker Noakh Menashe Braindel 1910 Warka, Poland None Yekhiel Vafel Cousin
Cantkert Fayga 1895 Warsaw, Poland Deportation List
Cantkert Frida 1939 Paris, France Deportation List
Cantkert Ita 1927 Paris, France Deportation List
Cantkert Paul 1933 Paris, France Deportation List
Cantkert Suzanne 1935 Paris, France Deportation List
Cantkier Yankiel Meir Hudes 1905 Warka, Poland Tauba George Cantkier Son
Cantkier Symcha 1919 Wolomin, Poland Teiblum Yerakhmiel Zholt Cousin
Cantkier Leja Teblum Leib Ester 1919 Wegrow, Poland Simkha Yerakhmiel Zhulti Cousin
Cantkier Unknown Symcha Leja 1939 Wolomin, Poland Yerakhmiel Zholt Cousin
Feder Reizl Tzantker Hersh Breina 1885 Warka, Poland Mordekhai Tzipora Haus Niece
Tantker Josif Shmuel Riza 1921 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Sara Hersh Breina 1918 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Bronia Khaim Reizil 1913 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Khaim Hersh Breina 1892 Warsaw, Poland Khaia Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Tzipora Hersh Breina 1920 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Neha Khaim Shmuel Khaia 1917 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Sofia Khaim Shmuel Khaia Roza 1915 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Yokheved 1910 Warsaw, Poland Yaakov Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Yitzhak Hersh Breina 1914 Warsaw, Poland Tzafrir Cousin
Tantker Yaakov Hersh Breina 1875 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Yaakov Hersh Breina 1910 Warsaw, Poland Yokheved Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Reizl Hersh Breina 1923 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Zelig Khaim Shmuel Khaia Roza 1919 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Khaia Reizl 1897 Warsaw, Poland Khaim Shmuel Tzipora Haus Cousin
Tantker Zelda Khaim Shmuel Khaia Roza 1912 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Zantker Frida Khaim Shmuel Khaia 1918 Warsaw, Poland Tzipora Haus Cousin
Zantker Sara Lange Khaim Barukh Tzina Bialobrzegi, Poland Efraim Shafranski Nephew
Zantker Wolf Bialobrzegi, Poland Sara Lange Efraim Shafranski Relative
Zantker Abraham Warka, Poland Efraim Shafranski Acquaintance
Zantker Nukha Wolf Sara 1930 Bialobrzegi, Poland Efraim Shafranski
Tzandker Yisrael Yosef Miriam 1907 Stanislawow, Poland Hendel Ishlakh Brother
Tzandker Ester Beniamin Khava 1906 Stanislawow, Poland Hendel Ishlakh
Tzandker Khaia Sara Yosef Miriam 1908 Wolomin, Poland Hendel Ishlakh
Tzandker Dvora Yosef Miriam 1923 Stanislawow, Poland Hendel Ishlakh
Tzandker Asher Yosef Miriam 1920 Stanislawow, Poland Hendel Ishlakh
Tzandker Meier Yosef Miriam 1900 Stanislawow, Poland Hendel Ishlakh Sister
Tzandker Tzipora Yosef Miriam 1900 Stanislawow, Poland Hendel Ishlakh Sister
Tzandker Sabina 1915 Warsaw, Poland Hendel Ishlakh Sister-in-Law
Tzandker Simkha Yosef Miriam 1923 Stanislawow, Poland Hendel Ishlakh
Tzandker Miriam Khaim David Rivka Matilda 1880 Stanislawow, Poland Hendel Ishlakh Daughter
Tzandker Khana Asher 14 Hendel Ishlakh
Tzandker David Tzipora 15 Hendel Ishlakh
Tzandker Yoel Tzipora 13 Hendel Ishlakh
Tzandker Khaia Tzipora 10 Hendel Ishlakh
Tzantker Malka 30 Poland Shalom Beniamin Tzantker Son
Tzantker Shalom Poland Malka Beniamin Tzantker Son
Tzantker Sara Khaia Asher Feiga 1927 Wyszkow, Poland Ester Shmit Sister
Tzantker Miriam Doba Yosef 60 Wyszkow, Poland Ester Shmit Granddaughter
Tzantker Yisrael Yosef Leib Miriam Doba 50 Warsaw, Poland Ester Shmit Niece
Tzantker Dvora Yosef Leib Miriam Doba Warsaw, Poland Ester Shmit Niece
Tzantker Asher Yosef Leib Miriam Doba 1890 Wyszkow, Poland Feiga Vengosh Ester Shmit Daughter
Tzantker Beila Shalom Malka 7 Poland Beniamin Tzantker Brother
Tzantker Sara Khaia Yosef Leib Marise Doba Warsaw, Poland Ester Shmit Aunt
Tzantker Meir Yekhiel Yosef Miriam Doba Wolomin, Poland Ester Shmit Niece
Tzantker Simkha Yosef Leib Miriam Doba Warsaw, Poland Ester Shmit Niece
Tzantker Khana Lea Asher Feiga 1920 Vishkov, Poland Ester Shmit Sister
Tzantker Levi 1907 Otwock, Poland Tzipora Zilbershtein Ofra Shaltiel Daughter
Tzantker 1890 Otwock, Poland Ofra Shaltiel Granddaughter
Tzantker Asher Yosef Miriam 1897 Stanislawow, Poland Feiga Vengosh Ester Shmit Daughter
Tzantker Sara Khaia Asher Feiga 1921 Wyszkow, Poland Shmuel Shmit Sister
Tzantker Khana Lea Asher Feiga 1918 Wyszkow, Poland Ester Shmit Sister

Survivor, Tzipora Haus, remembered several cousins with parents named Hersh and Breina. However, the birth years ranged from 1875 to 1923.  This is unlikely, unless there were at least two couples with the same names.  This isn't impossible. My second great grandmother is thought to have been born in 1865, so only Yaakov (1875) is a likely sibling. [And Tzipora submitted two pages of testimony for a Yaakov son of Hersh and Breina. The other had him born in 1910. Which recollection of hers was correct, or were there two Yaakovs?]

One thing this search revealed is that most of the names don't have a final 't'.  Even though I conducted the search on "Cantkert" the database was smart enough to realize that "Cantker" and its phonetic variants were synonyms.

When I checked at JewishGen I learned their search engine wasn't that flexible, and a search on Cantker revealed a few more entries my earlier searches missed.  Including a Rajzla (Rose?) Cantker born in Warka in 1870.  If my second great grandmother was actually born in 1870, she would only have been 13 when her eldest child was said to have been born in 1883. That borders on the unlikely, but we don't have a birth certificate for her eldest child. Her second child is supposed to have been born three years later in 1886, and her third child is supposed to have been born in 1889. There is certainly some flexibility here to allow for an 1870 birth.  [Especially if that's just an 1870 registration of birth, and the family waited to register her, as was sometimes the case.] So this is a record I am definitely going to try to obtain.

No comments: